Guilty by Deduction
Puzzle Arsenal · KDP & Etsy

Build gorgeous whodunit puzzle books at the push of a button and cash in on a genre earning thousands a month

Guilty by Deduction does all the work for you. Add your name, upload to Amazon or Etsy, and you’re in business.

Agent Logic holding the Guilty by Deduction box beside Agent Cipher
$1,600+
a month from one of our own puzzle books
1 click
builds your whole print-ready interior
Up to 200
verified cases in every book you build
Watch This First
The Money

Whodunit puzzle fans can’t stop buying, and they always want the next case

Logic-grid whodunits are one of the hottest money-makers in puzzle books right now. The top titles pull in thousands of dollars a month in royalties, and the biggest one sits in the top 20 of ALL books on Amazon. Not just puzzles. Everything.

And here’s the best part: these readers don’t stop at one. They finish a book and go straight looking for the next one, which is why a whodunit series can keep paying you, book after book.

A finished whodunit paperback standing beside an open copy showing a real Guilty by Deduction case
The real interior: a case spread straight out of Guilty by Deduction
$4,604 a day in royalties.

That’s BookBeam’s estimate for Murdle: Volume 1. One puzzle book, every single day. Readers want this format, and they want more of it.

Our Proof

Our own puzzle book is already bringing in over $1,600 a month

We don’t just make puzzle builders. We publish puzzle books too, and one of them is already earning more than $1,600 every single month on Amazon.

A phone on a detective’s desk showing a royalty payment notification, beside a laptop royalties chart and stacks of cash

That’s one book, made once, selling month after month. Now imagine a whole shelf of gorgeous whodunit books with your name on every cover.

That’s exactly what Guilty by Deduction helps you do.

The Numbers

The top whodunit puzzle books bring in six figures a month between them

These are BookBeam estimates for the 5 top-earning murder mystery logic puzzle books on Amazon, so you can see the demand for yourself.

Estimated monthly royalties
$368,280
from just 5 whodunit logic puzzle books
  1. Murdoku: 80 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles$165,360
  2. Murdle: Volume 1$138,120
  3. Murdoku: Around the World$34,590
  4. Murdoku: Back in Time$18,750
  5. Murdle: Volume 2$11,460
Source: BookBeam estimated sales (royalty per day x 30). Figures are estimates, not exact sales.

5 books. About $368,280 a month in estimated royalties.

Five books. Hundreds of thousands of dollars a month. And they keep adding new volumes and spin-offs, because readers keep coming back for more.

When one puzzle format can carry a whole series like that, you want in.

$138,120
est. royalties per month
567 - 4,725
est. copies sold per day
$4,604
est. royalty per day!
Stand Out

Plain grid books get ignored, while beautiful ones grab the sales

Plenty of publishers have tried to copy Murdle with plain black-and-white grids, and most of those books barely sell a copy a day. Puzzle lovers already own those books. All of them.

Readers aren’t tired of whodunits. They’re tired of boring ones. Put something stunning in front of them and they notice.

Three finished whodunit puzzle paperbacks with illustrated covers

That’s the gap Guilty by Deduction fills: the format readers already buy by the thousands, with illustrated case files that make your book stand out on the shelf.

The Evidence

The 3 top-earning whodunit puzzle books are printing money right now

Here are the 3 biggest earners in whodunit logic puzzles on Amazon. Look at what readers happily pay for: story-driven case books they can crack with a pencil and a little brain power.

Murdoku: 80 Murder Mystery Logic Puzzles cover
Exhibit A
Est. monthly royalties$165,360
544 to 1,863 copies a day
Murdle: Volume 1 cover
Exhibit B
Est. monthly royalties$138,120
567 to 4,725 copies a day
Murdoku: Around the World cover
Exhibit C
Est. monthly royalties$34,590
199 to 336 copies a day
Source: BookBeam estimated sales (royalty per day x 30). Figures are estimates, not exact sales.

Same genre. Same hungry readers. Now imagine your book right beside them, with fully illustrated case files that look like they came from a big publisher.

Inside the Book

Every case is a crime scene your readers get to solve themselves

Open book showing a real Guilty by Deduction theft case: illustrated suspect, item and location cards facing the clues and deduction grid

Murders and Thefts, Fully Drawn

Every spread pairs illustrated suspect, item and location cards with the clues and a deduction grid, all on 2 facing pages.

Open book showing the solved Case Zero worked example with the grid filled in

A Solved Case Zero Up Front

The worked example shows a finished grid and the final accusation, so new readers learn the game by watching it solved.

A pencil solving a real Guilty by Deduction case: the grid filled in and the final accusation written

This is the fun readers pay for

This is Case 1 straight from the builder, solved clue by clue the way your readers will: checks and crosses on the grid until only one answer is left, then the accusation.

Our Twist

Your books will look like a big publisher spent a fortune on them

Hands flipping through a real Guilty by Deduction book

Fully illustrated, from the first suspect to the final clue

Guilty by Deduction takes the bestselling logic-grid format readers already love and makes it gorgeous. Every case comes fully illustrated, from the first suspect to the final clue.

  • Illustrated case files. Engraved suspect portraits, items and rooms on every spread. Beautiful interiors that look like they cost a fortune to design.
  • Murder AND theft. A stolen diamond hits different from a poisoned teacup. Build all murders, all thefts, or a mix, and give readers variety they can feel.
  • Clues that make readers look. “The suspect in a feather boa” isn’t a name. Readers have to study the cards to crack it, and that’s the fun.
Meet Guilty by Deduction

A powerful generator that builds your entire book with a few clicks

This is the easy part. Guilty by Deduction builds the whole interior for you: title page, copyright page, a 2-page How to Solve guide, an optional solved Case Zero, every 2-page case spread and the answer key at the back.

No design software. No drawing grids. No checking puzzles by hand. A 25-case book comes out at about 84 pages, and you can go all the way up to 200 cases.

Murder, Theft or Mixed

Set the crime for the whole book. Bodies in the library, missing heirlooms, or a juicy mix of both that alternates case by case.

Easy, Medium, Hard or Progressive

Choose one level, or go Progressive so the book starts gentle and builds to Hard. Perfect for readers who like a challenge that grows.

Make Any Case Your Own

Rename the case, the house and the victim, or rewrite the intro. The clues and solution update as you type.

Swap Any Suspect

Don’t love the Butler? Swap him out. The builder rewrites the card clues and checks the case again, so it still has one answer.

Readers Know Exactly How to Play

A 2-page How to Solve guide with a worked example, plus a solved Case Zero up front, so nobody gets stuck on page 1.

Ready for Amazon and Etsy

3 trim sizes (8.5 x 11, 8 x 10 and 6 x 9). Export a print-ready PDF for KDP or 300 DPI PNG pages in a zip for Etsy.

Every export saves to My Books, so you can rebuild the exact same file any time.

Is This You?

Guilty by Deduction is perfect for you if

Agent Logic on the edge of a desk hugging a finished whodunit puzzle book, Agent Cipher behind her
Case fileSuspect: you
  • You want a simple way to make money with puzzle books on Amazon KDP or Etsy.
  • You want in on a puzzle genre where the top books earn thousands every month.
  • You want beautiful, illustrated books that stand out, without design software or drawing a single grid.
  • You love push-button easy, and you’re done with monthly fees.
VerdictGuilty of wanting puzzle books that sell
Get Instant Access

Get your first eye-catching whodunit book onto Amazon today

Agent Logic and Agent Cipher with the Guilty by Deduction box
  • The Guilty by Deduction builder in your Puzzle Arsenal account
  • Illustrated murder, theft and mixed cases
  • Easy, Medium, Hard or Progressive books of up to 200 verified cases
  • Every case verified to have exactly one solution
  • A 2-page How to Solve guide and an optional solved Case Zero
  • A full answer key, every case explained step by step
  • Print-ready PDFs for Amazon KDP and 300 DPI PNG pages for Etsy
  • 3 trim sizes, and every book saved in My Books
  • The right to publish and sell the books you create
Guilty by Deduction
$37
One-time payment. No monthly fees.
Build My First Case File
Instant access · Works in your browser · Nothing to install
Questions

You probably want to know

Do I need design skills or special software?

No. Guilty by Deduction runs in your browser. You make your choices, it lays out every page, and you download the finished file.

Do the puzzles actually work?

Yes. Every case is solved from scratch by the builder and verified to have exactly one solution, and the answer key at the back explains each one step by step.

Can I sell the books I make?

Yes. The books you create are yours to publish and sell on Amazon KDP, Etsy and beyond.

Your purchase is a license to use Guilty by Deduction. The builder itself is not for resale.

Can I change the stories and characters?

Yes. Rename any case, its house and its victim, rewrite the intro, or swap a suspect. The builder checks the case again after every change, so it still has one answer.

Does it make the cover too?

Guilty by Deduction builds the interior: every page inside the book. You add your own cover when you upload to KDP.

What files do I get?

A print-ready PDF for Amazon KDP, or a zip of 300 DPI PNG pages for Etsy. Choose 8.5 x 11, 8 x 10 or 6 x 9 before you export. Every book is saved in My Books so you can rebuild it any time.

What does Progressive difficulty mean?

You choose Easy, Medium or Hard for the whole book, or Progressive. A Progressive book starts gentle and builds to Hard, so readers ease in and keep going.

What does my license cover?

You get a Personal Publishing License. Publish and sell the books you make under your own name or pen names, on your own Amazon KDP, Etsy or website accounts, and keep 100% of your royalties.

It does not cover making books for clients, selling or giving away the PDFs or page images to other publishers, or sharing your login. Those need a Studio License. Read the full Terms and License.

Is it hard to learn?

No. Each builder works in your browser: you make your choices, it lays out every page, and you download the finished file. You can start with any one of them. Every book also comes with a How to Solve guide for your readers.

Is there a refund policy?

All sales are final, because you get instant access to digital software and files. Have a question before you buy? Our support team is happy to help you decide.

Are there monthly fees?

None. It’s a one-time payment.

Is anything shipped to me?

No. The box is just for fun. Guilty by Deduction is software you use online in your Puzzle Arsenal account.

Guilty by Deduction emblem

Grab your powerful whodunit book builder for just $37

Build your first illustrated whodunit puzzle book today.

Crack My First Case Today
Start My Whodunit Books